Tuesday, December 17, 2013

Hope for Paws- Eldad Hagar Abandoned over 100 Dogs after Collecting Thousands in Donations

Who remembers this story from May 2010?  Race Against the Clock to Save Over 100 Animals

There have been many questions & rumors surrounding ELDAD HAGAR & HOPE FOR PAWS rescue. Some of the things in question date back more than 2 years, but if you're in the business of saving lives you'll never forget this one. Many dogs were abandoned, donations went missing & dogs died. I think it might be important to bring these things up, especially when the organization is always winning big charity grants, raking in tons of money & yet always begging for your votes & donations, but seems to rescue only a handful of dogs & has no animals up for adoption on their website.  

Also, just as an FYI. Hope for paws is NOT a new hope partner which means they do NOT rescue shelter animals. They never have. They don't take animals into their rescue & they don't even post animals up for adoption on their page- they give them off to other rescues once they catch and videotape. The only thing Eldad & HFP really push for is votes for winning money.

A few years ago, there was a hoarding case in Palmdale, CA that Eldad Hagar (Hope For Paws) was involved in http://sangabrielpets.wordpress.com/2010/05/11/hope-for-paws-rescues-over-100-dogs-from-hoarder-in-palmdale/ where he collected over 15 thousand dollars in donations. Most of those 100+ dogs he "rescued" were later abandoned, some shipped off to other states without even a vet exam, left in boarding or some even sent to high kill shelters where one shelter (Irvine) even wrote to Eldad to please come back & get the dogs he left, which he refused. 
Some dogs were left for over 18 months in boarding by Eldad who didn't even look back or try to help these dogs. Other rescues had to step up and re-rescue the dogs left behind minus the donation money. He basically took the money and ran. There are court records that prove Eldad abandoned those dogs at boarding without payment.  
Case Number: 10S01264
Filing Date: 07/07/2010Case Type: Small Claims (Limited Jurisdiction)Filing Court: San Fernando Courthouse

A side note that is interesting: When Milan Radovic (the owner of Top Dog Resort, where Eldad dumped all the dogs & left) took him to court & won for non payment of these dumped dogs from Palmdale, Eldad's wife, Audrey, spoke on his behalf, while Eldad stood there silently & she told the judge the reason why he didn't understand the payment situation or fees was because Eldad could not understand or speak English very well. How many of you have heard him speak in his videos, in person or on the phone? There are hundreds of people who can attest to Eldad speaking perfect English. 

Upon hearing of the abandonment of all the dogs, the Executor of the  AZ dogs demanded via phone & letter those dogs he was given to  be returned to the estate. She did not like or approve of Eldad or Sharon Gold dumping the dogs.  

Speaking of Sharon Gold... she was also convicted of embezzlement and did prison time.  Yeah, great pair these two.,   She now lives in Washington State, operating a dog rescue, harassing fosters.  One foster claims she is very abusive with kicking dogs.  A transport told how she was bragging about how stupid people were because it was so easy to take their money.  

Eldad also had two dogs (Basenji's) killed that he "rescued" from Palmdale.  He and Sharon deemed them dangerous without even getting them properly evaluated.  They never even had a chance.   Milan at Top Dog and another witness can attest to this lack of compassion and total disregard to the right of life perpetrated by Eldad.

Let's not forget about the female Labrador left in a crate in Arizona to die a miserable death, melting in the hot desert sun.  A concerned citizen went back to find this horrifying sight. 
Eldad, Sharon and one other rescue were the last two to leave the site and this poor girl was left behind.  

 The only reason Eldad even bothered to "volunteer" to re-rescue the dogs he left behind was to save face. Eldad stole thousands of dollars in donations that were meant for these animals. And what's even worse are those who know the truth, yet continue to support Eldad. Why are people continuing to support him? Wake up... this is NOT rescue. I don't know any other rescue that is always armed with a video camera at every rescue & thinks that the best shots on film is the most important part of the rescue. In most other rescues, the animals are of first concern & a making a great video is only an afterthought.

The rescue of the abandoned dogs is credited to the many rescues that pulled together for the sake of the animals....one of those rescues being Pulling for Paws & others. They worked hard and tirelessly without the money or pats on the back to ensure the dogs abandoned by Eldad did not get left behind again. I commend those rescues that took on this mission without question. Eldad is NOT a hero, in my opinion...he's a fraud, a con, a marketeer...who's greatest achievement is tugging the heartstrings of thousands while dipping into their pocket books. It seems the main point behind this man is make a few great videos, & push them out all over Godvine, Facebook & other social networking sites, for maximum recognition & donations. How many animals does he really rescue a year? A handful? Is he a glorified dog catcher? Many of the dogs he uses in his videos are turned over to other rescues to care for after the initial, glorifying save & video.   http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e6zvLGN8C58  


Witness A
Eldad left one of those dogs from palmdale/az hoarding case behind in a crate to die in the AZ sun.....but he didnt get that on film......many.of the.dogs were dumped in boarding at Top Dog in California. We took one of those dogs and it's hard to look at him and think he could of been the one left behind in the crate. 

Witness BI witnessed this one with my own eyes & put my own reputation at stake. Not good. These animals were abandoned by them & good people's donations were not going to the animals in need. Quite a shame. I can name at least 5 rescues who came in & saved those dogs that Eldad abandoned yet took the donation money. And yes, some died, not just that one in the desert.

Witness C
Eldad & I worked together when he responded to helping me with an ongoing cat hoarding situation... only to leave me feeling completely used once he got footage to show he was a cat rescuer, as well. Created videos asking for money, then BAILED on ALL of us!! And I'm putting all that nicely & in a nutshell. It was ugly & WRONG!! There are a lot of details on specific situations where he acted like scum. I was shocked. Thought he was a hero, too. Add another 20-25 cats/kittens to the animals on which he's bailed but collected $$$.

He also nearly killed a litter of kittens by grabbing a tube of Frontline saying, "gimme that... let ME do it" (cuz he claims to also be going to VET school). Turned out he used up the entire tube VS. one drop per kitten. Two of them crashed, were rushed to emergency vet in Eagle Rock. After the vet helped stabilize, he picked up the worse one, said , "no sense letting it die at the vet & paying the overnight stay", took the kitten home, shot video of him with another rescue dog cuddling in a bed", submitted it to the Bonnie Hunt Show where he made THAT video go viral, collect more donation monies & fans, bad-mouthed that vet... saying, "he saved Hunter's life". Ewww, I better stop now... I'm gonna throw up.

Witness D
The Chase Community Giving grant is over and I am RELIEVED!! We did NOT get enough votes to secure a spot on the leader board which means we will NOT be receiving any of the grant. I am a rescuer, I spend my days scooping poop, racing to the shelter to make sure dogs are safe or to the vet to make sure they are well, facilitating dogs being pulled to safety, transporting dogs, responding to emails from potential adopter's, arranging home checks, weeding through applications and networking dogs in danger. I do not have time to video tape every dog I rescue, every trip to the shelter or set up live stream cameras while I wash puppies for your votes. I don't have the money to buy expensive ads on Facebook promoting myself nor do I have the huge network of supporter's in the states and/or over seas to bring in votes. If you voted for us I hope it was because you know I work hard, genuinely love & care for animals, and deserved the money.

Witness E
Why bother, the masses are STUPID - they want to believe in fairy tale BS - no one wants to be a part of the WORK it really takes to save an animal - sure, I'm off to WASH my rescued pitbull & shep..tune in...it's FREE, it's not glamorous....that SOB Eldad has left dogs to die, abandoned an old chow & left a pittie on the street left a dog to die in a crate & WTF - keep on sending HIM money..I give up.

Rebuttal to Witness E by Witness B
I bother because there ARE good & decent rescues & rescuers out there who never get a chance, any donations, or any accolades for all the hard work they do day & night to save animals. I bother because this is absurd what is going on with Eldad & how people are snowed. I bother because the animals matter most to me of all.

The other concerning thing is he has won the Chase Charities giveaway again ( in addition to a Toyota Highland this year & other contests).. He's won 4 years in a row, first as Hope for Paws & then in following years by partnering with The Kris Kelly Foundation, & just this past week where he partnered with another Foundation winning $100,000. I don't even think you're allowed to enter more than one year in a row. I guess "partnering" with another organization is a way to get around this. But how many small rescues rake in over $100K a year? This is public record for a non profit & this was just in 2010. How much money is spent on advertising? How much money actually goes to the animals in need? It may deserve closer examination.

For those who want a second opinion, there is another blog for you to read that was researched independently and her findings are outlined in great detail.  is-hope-for-paws-shady-hollywood

Eldad abandoned so many dogs from a Palmdale rescue at Top Dog Resort.He said he'd get them all spay/neutered, vaccinated, microchipped, rehomed etc.... he did not and yet he took about $15,000 in donations.

Eldad and Sharon said they were in Arizona getting 12 dogs off an estate, came back with 11.  One of those dogs was left behind to die a miserable death. 

Several other rescues had to step in to vet the dogs,spay/neuter, find them homes etc, on their own dime without the recognition they deserved for saving the dogs he abandoned.

Eldad also had 2 dogs from Palmdale euthanized at Top Dog resort he considered dangerous without having them properly evaluated first..

Some of the dogs were abandoned for over 18 months.

Pulling for Paws took a majority of these dogs along with other rescue orgs. Their names are all at the end of that video, Rescue Uncovered, on youtube.

Eldad was sued in court and lost.


In conclusion
Real rescues don't have time to go out and video tape everything they do, let alone edit the video adding haunting music & text and then posting all over the world. That does NOT make you a top rescue, that makes you a video editor & marketeer and to use God to profit from is appalling. If you're going to support a rescue, please support a real rescue that doesn't abandon dogs everywhere, or leave them in crates in the hot desert sun as they drive away in an air conditioned van with all the donation money. Please make sure who your donating to is really concerned about the animals they claim to 'rescue'.

Reviews can be read here.
        Listed below are screenshots of some of the reviews.


  1. I think you are lying and I don't know why.

  2. is this really true??? my goodness!.. i can't believe he can do that!!

  3. How much of this can be proven? I am not finding much regarding this. I am not sure how much of this I believe. I believe he may owe boarding costs, but to accuse someone of the heinous acts is pretty big. I also do dog rescue and I know how much other rescues and supposed rescues like to run their mouths. I am going to have to stick with innocent until proven guilty.

  4. Ridiculous fake documents... Even a blind dog would see that.

  5. i can tell you for 100% that the above story or any other claims of that manner are completely false! Eldad, which i know personally, would be the last person on earth needing 15K......
    Besides that i know him more than 10 years and within those years have seen him rescue numerous dogs.

    Please be assured, the above story is NOT true....

    Louis. P

    1. Who are YOU? A friend helping a friend is all I see. Why should I be "reassured" because a stranger tells me Eldad is ok afterall?

    2. Who are you true hope? another ignorant hater

    3. I just donated for a month and registered for 12 months, but after that I stumbled upon this article and some more. I have some other rescuer friends and inquired from them too. Most of this article it true. Wow this is really unbelievable!!! I will have to figure out how to retract for the rest of the payments, I would rather give my donation where they really need it.

  6. The judgment is not fake. You can find it at the Los Angeles Superior Court website: http://www.lasuperiorcourt.org/civilcasesummarynet/ui/casesummary.aspx?CT=CI

    The site does not give details of the case itself, but of the financial claim and the judgment against Hope For Paws. Subsequently the matter was moved to Van Nuys, and that information is also available on the website (it says, essentially, the same thing as the San Fernando case): http://www.lasuperiorcourt.org/civilcasesummarynet/ui/casesummary.aspx?CT=CI

    1. You need case numbers to see the details of a case. Do you have those?

    2. case number: 10S01364 dated July 7, 2010

  7. All I can say is WOW....... I am shocked....... Considered donating, but never did and I can say I am happy I didn't. I won't be watching any HFP videos in the future. They should be ashamed....

    1. You are a fool if you believe this crap, and you should keep your money. I am sure your children need it.

  8. I find little to no evidence here. I don't believe that Eldad would do any of this. I mean why even bother acting like such a kind person? I truly think that he does good. And everyone else should too. This article is fake. Read this if you want to actually see what he and his wife are like: http://moderndogmagazine.com/articles/hope-paws/38502

    1. I wouldn't go so far as to say the article is fake. It's not fake but some of it is misleading. Read the rebuttal at the end and it explains that Eldad had no idea that the dog in Arizona was left behind. In addition, the judge compromised with regard to the dispute between Eldad and the kennel. It sounds to me like Eldad may be guilty of spreading himself too thin at times, but overall I think he does very good work.

    2. That's how a con artist works. They're the kindest people you can possibly imagine. They prey on peoples vulnerability and hearts to get what they want. This is totally true and you can find all the court documents above in other people's posts.

  9. Nobody is perfect. Eldad is only one person. It sounds to me like he never likes to say no to a rescue. He may not be able to follow up on every single rescue he does, especially when he rescues multiple dogs at once. But I think he does the best he can and overall it sounds to me like he does really good work and saves a lot of dogs.

    I think the criticism of his videos is totally unfounded. Not only do the videos help to find homes for the dogs, but the videos raise a lot of money and that money is used for rescues. Eldad would not be able to rescue nearly as many dogs if he didn't fundraise. When Eldad finds one dog, I think it is usually pretty easy for him to find the dog a home thanks to the publicity from the videos.

    But when Eldad rescues 50 dogs from a hoarding situation or that type of thing, it takes time to find homes. The dogs may have to be boarded and that is very expensive. Fundraising is very important to pay for boarding and that type of thing. Fundraising is an absolute necessity. The videos are great for fundraising. The videos are a good thing, not a bad thing. They highlight the type of work being done and they raise money to save more dogs. I don't know how anyone can criticize the videos.

  10. Another piece of trash smear blog who has an axe to grind. Dispicable. The author of this blog has made a personal campaign against Eldad across the intrenet never giving out their real name.

    1. Wow are you ever gullible! He hasn't actually rescued that many dogs in actuality. Seems like it but he hasn't and yet the dollars keep pouring in for him . He may have cleaned up his act for a while but it's only bc of his bad publicity that he did so.

  11. People, stop, drop, roll. Put out the fire. Check Google. A quick search does not reveal much more than the positive work HFP has done. Put on your critical thinking caps: Let's say for the sake of argument that what's been written here is true. Why are there only two names associated with any of it -besides this blogger? Okay, find this Diana Tippit AND Christine Franco. Look up the shelter mentioned. Call them & inquire after these stories you've heard. The court case is a matter of public record ->VERIFY THESE THINGS.

    For all we know, the very sad picture of the dog above may be real, but we have no context for it. We don't know if it's even related to what they're saying about HFP, so don't jump to conclusions! Critical thinking is what's called for. Always verify everything, or at least as much as you can. The internet is a tricky place!

  12. Exactly! If this were true, it would be all over the place. The court case? So what? It's a dispute over money. I don't believe a word of this and now I think I will double my donation.

    1. OMG you think every case makes the web? He's one guy nobody cares too much about as far as the media goes that's why you can't find anything. As far as doubling your donation you go ahead and throw away your money. Even if there's the off chance you're wrong then it is just stupid of you to double your donation when there are other charities out there that have impeccable reputations. Not sure what you think anyone has to gain by making things up about this fraud.

  13. I've been watching Hope for Paws videos for over a week now and with each video I cannot help but cry. The heroic act taken by Eldad and his friends would appear very convincing since I am about to sacrifice and donate for his rescues. I could not believe how people would use hopeless and helpless dogs as an income opportunity where I on the other hand is constantly surviving for over 15 years now trying to provide a caring environment for my rescued cats and dogs. I live in a country where most people have no clue about animal rights when even kids would a tiny kitten. I am living in a third world country and stray dogs and cats are not treated with respect. Each day for us is a battle while I am trying hard to provide for my furry friends from the meager income that I make balancing it between my family of 7 and family of 12 furry friends. On most times I feel I am neglected my rescues since I could not provide them with proper medical care. I am sacrificing so much for these animals because I genuinely feel it is the right thing to do, if I am not able to help and welcome them then who will. It is a constant battle on a day to day basis, fearing that someone will hurt any of my furry family, always on the look out for people around us who dislike dogs and cats. Aside from the challenge of providing a safe shelter and food for my animal family, dealing with the constant abuse on animals around me is one cross that I have to bear alone. I have no help from anybody, no funds, no donations, no solicitation I am all by myself wanting to stay strong for all of them. I did not chose them by they chose me...it is so amazing that these cats and dogs know where to turn to for help. Here in the Philippines you will see newly born kittens in plastic bags, dogs left to wander the streets, kittens dumped on the streets and the growing injustices of animal abuse like dog catcher who scout around for dog meat- which I have learn to deal with on a day to day basis. Just imagine the pain I have to go through each day turning a blind eye and deaf ears to the cries of the newly born which I am powerless not able to help them. Sometimes I have to place cotton on my ears just to muffled the sound from the cries of the kittens outside. I am guilty sometimes of wishing that these tiny kittens will die quickly to spare them the torment and pain of being neglected and be subjected to torture by even small kids. For any animal lover being in this situation is unbearable but I need to muster the strength to carry on and continue to fight for the very existence of my furry family and for the ones who will be lucky enough to sense that I am just here for them. The fear is always there- the constant conflict that I have to endure just to keep my furry friends safe and alive. I have to remain strong and always hopeful that I will be able to fulfill my mission here on this planet. I am always praying to the Supreme Being for some guidance and blessings.

  14. This comment has been removed by the author.

  15. "Real rescues don't have time to go out and video tape everything they do, let alone edit the video adding haunting music & text and then posting all over the world."
    Maybe they should make the time.

    1. this comment makes me wonder how stupid the human race can be

    2. this comment makes me wonder how stupid the human race can be

  16. This comment has been removed by the author.

  17. Eldad gives thousands of $$'s to help other rescuers!! he is always there for us when we need him!! Id'e personally like to know who wrote this article. probably someone who is jealous and didnt get what they expected!! with an axe to grind! and btw you dont need to be a new hope partner to be a rescuer, that is the most rediculous statement i've ever read in my life!! really stupid!!

  18. and btw you can remove my comment like youve removed so many others, why hide them?? because you are lying!!